Please contact us to learn more about these amazing cookies!


 Welcome to
 Mitch's Cookies
Follow Us On:

Amazing Gourmet recipes, Mitch combines the best ingredients with a secret mixing technique that produces a huge cookie that has a cake-like texture and soft chewy center. We provide first class gift packages to companies and consumers. Experience Mitch's “Signature Chocolate Chip Cookie” and savor the difference.


Our specialties include Chocolate Chip, Oatmeal Chocolate Chip, Oatmeal Raisin, Plain Oatmeal, Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip, Plain Peanut Butter, Reese's Peanut Butter Chip and Chocolate Chip COMBO, Snickerdoodle, Coconut Pecan and many other specialty cookies.


INTRODUCING Mitch's Cake-like Sugar Cookies; Lemon Drop, Raspberry Filled, Carmel Apple Filled, Strawberry Filled and Blueberry Filled -  so good! -  Must try these!


Follow Us On:
New Location
Mitch's Cookie Dessert Bar & Soda Fountain

520 Park Street Location, Just off 5th Avenue Downtown Naples

We are on the move! This location is closed and we will be moving to a location on 5th Avenue S to ready for the upcoming season.  Stay Tuned for additional information. 

Mitch's Cookie Dessert Bar & Soda Fountain

Kings Lake Square Location
Monday Closed
Tues - Sun 1:00 to 9:00

"Take a step in time and create some new Old Fashioned Memories"
Meet our Soda Jerks
Hunter, Kat, Layla, Yasmin and Nat 
Mitch's Private Label Options are Available 

WOW Creations Produces "Beat Bobby Flay" Official Gift Bag
For the Third Year WOW Creations partners with Bobby Flay, 1/20/2015 - New York, N.Y. "Beat Bobby Flay" the hit show on Food Network partners with Los Angeles based WOW Creations for the third season and receives their Fabulous Celebrity Gift Bags.

WOW Creations does it again and provides their Gift Bags to season four of "Beat Bobby Flay". Some of the Great celebrities receiving the Gift Bags this season are Rachel Ray, Bobby Flay, Al Roker, Anne Burrell, Giada De'Laurentiis, Cameron Diaz, Garth Brooks, John Legend, Emeril Lagasse, Mary Hart and Mario Lopez just to name a few.

Some of the exciting brands that participated in the Gifting was: Magic, Brittle Bliss, The Container Store, Shade-pop, rockin Wellness, The Spice Lab, Ponderosa Coffee, Spam, Oxy Clean Dishwasher Soap, Jimbos Low Country, Stubbees, Cottage Kitchen Foods, Citrus Blossom candles, Jesse Steel Aprons, Naturres Shea butter, Meacham Hams,

Jarlsberg Cheese, Wild Hibiscus, Lees Rubs, Ashleys Sweet Chips, Tea and Time for You, Pardoes Perky Peanuts, Ehlenbachs Cheese, Mitch's Cookies, Red Hen Gourmet, Marilyh Schiff Jewelry, Dippin Chips, Sarah Skinny Sweets, Arteatables, His Glory Cutting Boards.

And that is just some of the brands that were included. Stay tuned for details of air dates and when season Five "Beat Bobby Flay" Gift Bags will be produced.

Mitch's Party tray - An assortment of Mini-Mitch Cookies -
Order your party tray for all your sports and other events!
Introducing Mitch's Cookies' elf Chip - Follow us on Facebook to see what he us up to this holiday season
Giggle Moon Naples - Private label
Private Label
powered by Mitch's Cookies

Personalized Mitch's Cookie Hat
Mitch's Cookies' Huge Party Tray

Mitch's Cookies support a local Soccor team donating half of the cookie money to their program

Mitch's Cookies can be found at the Second Cup Coffe Shop located in Mercato shopping center in Naples Florida

  Mitch's Cookies Dessert Bar 
 & Soda Fountain

 4844 Davis Blvd.
Kings Lake Square
 Naples, Florida

(239) 331-3212

 552 Lincoln Avenue
 Winnetka, IL

(224) 255-6272 

Press Release April 19, 2021

Mitch's Cookies continues their expansion plan opened up their 3rd location in Winnetka, IL

Press Release June 11th, 2020

Mitch's Cookies Dessert Bar & Soda Fountain: After years on Davis Boulevard, Mitch's opened a second location Jan. 11 in the former Adelheidi's Gelato space at 520 Park St. off of Fifth Avenue South. The shop offers egg creams, sundaes, malts, shakes and the giant, scratch-baked cookies for which Mitch's is known. More at or 

Press Release June 18th, 2020

Mitch’s Cookies Sweetens The Deal, Brings Back Old Fashioned Memories To The Hoffmann Family of Companies.

The Hoffmann Family of Companies has added Mitch’s Cookies, a small old-fashioned soda shop and dessert bar, to their growing list of small family run companies. The husband and wife team of Lynn and Mitch Mitchell will maintain minority ownership and continue to run and
operate at their current location with their team of “Soda Jerks” on Davis Blvd in Naples, FL next to Tacos and Tequila Cantina. 

Established in 2013, Mitch’s Cookies theme came from feedback from customers who enjoyed their cake-like but chewy gourmet cookie creations. The consistent message from those customers was a reminder of grandma’s cookies and childhood memories. From there, the
concept of “taking a step back in time and create new old-fashioned memories” was used to create the old-fashioned themed dessert bar and soda shop. 

Awarded Reader’s Choice Dining Award in 2020 for “best dessert place” by Naples Illustrated, Mitch’s Cookies has over 50 different exclusive gourmet cookie recipes including other menu items such as milkshakes,
sundaes, floats, egg creams, ice cream sandwiches and other desserts as well as gift options Mitch reminisces “It all started with a spiral notebook and a pen. I had been baking cookies for years, giving them away to family and friends at Christmas and the comments were always the
same, “You should sell these, they are that good!”, “Your cookies brought back some great memories of my grandmother as they reminded me of her old fashioned chewy cookies.” Lynn Mitchell adds “We are excited to be part of the Hoffmann Family of Companies and look forward to the expansion of our gourmet cookies and concept.”

With the acquisition comes expansion, with plans to put Mitch's Cookies in downtown Naples, grow alongside Tacos and Tequila with the opening of new locations, opening of a store in Winnetka, IL on their mainstreet as well as offering in other Hoffmann family owned businesses. “I will admit, and I know I shouldn’t, but if I was left alone with a box of Mitch’s Cookies they’d be
gone within the hour. Lynn and Mitch are amazing people, I’ve known them for a number of years and am glad to finally have access to an unlimited supply of their cookies as well as bring two additional small business owners to our family. We invest in the people behind the
businesses, this is what we believe it most. It’s the people that make the business, not just the product.” - David Hoffmann

The Hoffmanns are the largest commercial real estate owners in Naples with 33 properties
valued north of $500million and have now purchased 29 operating businesses in FL, a majority
in the hospitality and service industry.

For More Information:


Customer Comments

"Hi there!

 I just wanted you to know how amazing I think your cookies are!  I had one at ASH when we brought our little dog Maisie in when she had a very upsetting illness and ultimate diagnosis of cancer in December.  She is doing better and so are we but today I was back and was reminded that I wanted to write you about your cookies, to tell you that I love them and also that my husband and I buy one each time we visit Second Cup.  I have grandsons coming in for a visit in February and I will be ordering cookies and a cookie jar just for their visit plus possibly sending some up to my mom in Northern Michigan.  I am telling everyone about your product!  Thank you."

Pati M



"I had to settle for a Milano Cookie since I have eaten all of the Mitch's Cookies that were in the house..."  Joe from Scarborough, Maine


"I paid $2.25 for a cookie at the movies and that was no Mitch's Cookie" - James from Lakeland, Florida

"When the bag is empty, I take the crumbs and put them on top of vanilla ice cream. Good to the last crumb!" - Susan from Cumberland Foreside, Maine

"I have been eating Mitch's Cookies for the past 13 years and every cookie is the best cookie I have ever had" - Bob from Naples, Florida

"These cookies are amazing, I get a chocolate chip in every bite" - Dave, Ambassador at the Naples Florida Chamber of Commerce

"Holy Cow! I just picked up two dozen of the most delicious cookies! For anyone  who hasn't yet,  you GOTTA try these! Thanks Mitch" - Michelle from Naples, Florida
"I just had one of your Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip Cookies and WOW I love the peanut butter" - Ross from Naples, Florida
"I saw the Naples Daily News article on Mitch's Cookies on July 27th and went right to Second Cup Coffee Shop and bought an Oatmeal Raisin. I wanted a Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip and Oatmeal Chocolate Chip but they did not have any so I went to Sweetwater's and Pelican Larry's on only found Chocolate Chip. My solution was to go directly to Mitch's Cookies and ordered what I wanted. Great Service and Great Cookies!"  - Lynne from Riverview, MI.